Outsourcing vs. In-House Maintenance: What’s Best for Your Scottsdale Vacation Rental?

Table of Contents

When you own a vacation rental, you need to make sure that everything is in top condition. When everything is working as it should, your guests will be happy. This leads to more reviews and it can also lead to more bookings.

You can also avoid huge fees in the future when you ensure the maintenance of your vacation rental. 

The question now is, should you just DIY the maintenance or handle it in-house? Or should you outsource it?

Let’s break down the difference between the outsourcing and handling the maintenance in-house in this article, so you can figure out which option might work best for you Scottsdale vacation rental.

Pros and Cons of Outsourcing Maintenance

Outsourcing Maintenance



Access to Expertise

You can connect with professionals who have specialized training for the tasks you need them to do.

You’ll have less control over the maintenance process. If you get different people, the service quality might differ too.

Cost Efficiency

Overall expenses could be reduced. You wouldn’t have to hire a full-time staff or spend money on equipment and supplies.

Initial expenses might be higher. The ongoing costs depend on how much you’re going to need the service and the scope of it. 


When you outsource and let them handle the maintenance, you can focus on other aspects of your vacation rental.

You’ll have less direct control over the process and the service quality.

Quality Assurance

Hiring professionals also mean that you get a high standard of service quality. It’s also consistent and reliable.

You may have concerns with quality control.

Geographic Reach

You’ll have access to a network of service locations. This ensures consistent service quality on all operational areas.

There is less direct oversight of daily operations.

Reduced Overhead

You can avoid large capital expenses that usually come with setting up and running your own in-house shop.

The long-term costs could possibly be higher.

Pros and Cons of In-House Maintenance

In-House Maintenance



Control and Customization

You’ll have direct control over everything. So you can assess the quality of work done. You can also customize the protocols and schedules as you see fit.

You might need to invest a large sum on infrastructure and tools. You’ll also need to spend money and time in the training the staff.

Immediate Access and Response

You have immediate access to the maintenance staff and the facilities so you can respond immediately if there is an issue.

It requires management and someone has to supervise the rest of the maintenance staff.

Long-term Cost Benefits

There is a potential for long-term cost savings because you won’t have to pay for outsourcing fees.

There is a higher fixed costs. This includes salaries, benefits, and training expenses.

Staffing and Expertise

Direct control over staff activities. You can also build a team that aligns with the company’s goals.

You might encounter staffing challenges. It might be challenging to find qualified staff and you also need to retain them.

Customized Care

Ability to train employees to meet specific standards tailored to the properties.

Managing an in-house maintenance department is complex and time-consuming.

Building Relationships

Development of personal relationships between employees, management, and guests. This enhances trust and loyalty.

Managing logistics and asset management can be challenging and similar to running a separate business.

4 Key Factors to Consider Before Choosing Your Maintenance

Property Size and Complexity

The first key factor you need to consider is the size and complexity of your vacation rental. If your vacation rental, along with the rest of your properties, are massive, it might be more worth it to investing in an in-house team. With extensive grounds and even multiple units to look after, you’re probably going to need more frequent maintenance done. 

If you have a smaller vacation rental, you might need less frequent maintenance. So, outsourcing may be more practical for you.

Budget and Resources

Of course, you should always take into account your budget and resources. Can you afford the initial investment and the ongoing costs of an in-house maintenance team? Do you have the time and even the skills to manage and train them effectively for the job? 

You also need to look at the long-term costs. The initial costs of an in-house team may be greater but if you think you can get the returns sooner, then may be it’s worth the shot.

If you think you can’t handle the expenses for now, you should consider outsourcing first.

Availability of Local Services

There are many professional services in Scottsdale, Arizona that specialize in vacation rental maintenance. You first need to consider the quality and reliability of their services. Are they suitable for your standards? Be sure to research and check reviews. Look at their rates too if you think it’s something suitable for you. If you can directly talk to the people who have worked with them, it will also be better.

Your Personal Involvement

Now, do you want to be hand-on with the maintenance tasks? If you prefer more control or just a more hands-on approach, it might be better to get an in-house team. If you don’t have the time or you just want the professionals to handle it, you can outsource the maintenance tasks. 

Hybrid Approach: The Best of Both Worlds?

If you’re still not sure which one to choose, maybe a hybrid approach would work for you. 

You can use an in-house staff for routine tasks like regular cleaning and minor repairs around the vacation rental. If you have more complex issues like needing an HVAC maintenance or pool repairs, you can outsource professional help. 

A hybrid approach also allows flexibility. During the low seasons in Scottsdale, you can just keep the in-house staff. During the peak season, you can outsource additional help to manage the increased workload. 

Practical Tips Before Making A Decision

Assess Your Needs

You need to conduct a thorough evaluation of your property’s maintenance requirements. Make a list of tasks that need regular attention and maintenance and list of tasks that might need more specialized help.

Get Quotes and References

Compare costs and check references from other property owners. This will give you a better understanding of what to expect in terms of service quality and pricing. Ask fellow Scottsdale vacation rental owners about their experiences and recommendations.

Start Small

If you don’t want to commit to anything long-term, consider doing trial periods first with outsourcing companies or a part-time in-house staff. This allows you to test the waters first before fully committing. See which options work for you and your budget.

Your Maintenance Strategy

Outsourcing and in-house maintenance each have their own pros and cons. The right choice depends on what you and your vacation rental needs. It also depends on your budget and how involved you want to be.

Remember, it’s important to tailor you decision to your property. What works for one vacation rental might not work for another. Take the time to evaluate your options and choose which one works for you.

For more personalized advice and professional maintenance services, vacation rental management companies like Cactus Vacation Rentals can help you out.

Our expert team can help you determine the best maintenance strategy for your property so your Scottsdale vacation rental stays in excellent condition.

Contact Cactus Vacation Rentals today and let us handle everything so your vacation rental stands out and stays booked in the competitive Scottsdale market.


Latest posts